Durante la partita tra MONGOLS e ITALIAN CITY STATE si è verificata una situazione particolare … … un’unità di HC in Riserva fa dietro front e si disordina.
Nel turno successivo di movimento decide di fare una manovra complessa (rotazione di 6”) per poter caricare un’unità di LC nemica.
E’ possibile?
Secondo il regolamento, un’unità disordinata NON può fare manovre complesse … … ma un’unità in riserva può eseguire una rotazione di 4” senza disordinarsi.
Conta più l’essere in RISERVA o in DISORDINE?
L’amico Martin ha posto la questione sul yahoogroups di Armati; di seguito Vi riporto il dibattito:
MARTIN:
“ A special case: one unit HC is deployed as Reserve. After a "about face" this unit is disordered.
Is this unit able to perform a complex manovre like a extended wheel?
La risposta di MARK GRINDLAY
“So long as the conditions for making a reserve wheel are still fulfilled, a disordered reserve is still a reserve.
But an opportune advance into charge reach by a unit of light cavalry would place that reserve in some trouble if it is facing the wrong way and already disordered.
La risposta di VINCENT AUGER:
“To answer completely the initial question, you may not do an extended wheel (up to 6" wheel) while disordered, but you may still do reserve wheels (up to 4" wheel) even if disordered (obviously this assumes that all other conditions for being in reserve are satisfied).
About the reserve conditions, I umpire that the extreme flank zone (up to 18" from long table edge and within 6" of short table edge) are part of the deployment area for the reserve rule conditions.
I.e. moving a reserve division in that zone does not prevent it from doing more reserve wheels if it remains out of charge reach and with a straight front.
In attesa della risposta di Stephen Phenow, per ulteriori sviluppi e approfondimenti potete collegarVi a:
http://games.groups.yahoo.com/group/ARMATI/
Voi come la pensate?
Nel turno successivo di movimento decide di fare una manovra complessa (rotazione di 6”) per poter caricare un’unità di LC nemica.
E’ possibile?
Secondo il regolamento, un’unità disordinata NON può fare manovre complesse … … ma un’unità in riserva può eseguire una rotazione di 4” senza disordinarsi.
Conta più l’essere in RISERVA o in DISORDINE?
L’amico Martin ha posto la questione sul yahoogroups di Armati; di seguito Vi riporto il dibattito:
MARTIN:
“ A special case: one unit HC is deployed as Reserve. After a "about face" this unit is disordered.
Is this unit able to perform a complex manovre like a extended wheel?
La risposta di MARK GRINDLAY
“So long as the conditions for making a reserve wheel are still fulfilled, a disordered reserve is still a reserve.
But an opportune advance into charge reach by a unit of light cavalry would place that reserve in some trouble if it is facing the wrong way and already disordered.
La risposta di VINCENT AUGER:
“To answer completely the initial question, you may not do an extended wheel (up to 6" wheel) while disordered, but you may still do reserve wheels (up to 4" wheel) even if disordered (obviously this assumes that all other conditions for being in reserve are satisfied).
About the reserve conditions, I umpire that the extreme flank zone (up to 18" from long table edge and within 6" of short table edge) are part of the deployment area for the reserve rule conditions.
I.e. moving a reserve division in that zone does not prevent it from doing more reserve wheels if it remains out of charge reach and with a straight front.
In attesa della risposta di Stephen Phenow, per ulteriori sviluppi e approfondimenti potete collegarVi a:
http://games.groups.yahoo.com/group/ARMATI/
Voi come la pensate?
